A Southern music

This past weekend, a bunch of us drove around 200 miles to go listen to T M Krishna, Sriramkumar and Arun Prakash perform at Seattle and came back with our hearts desires fulfilled at the concert. Early disclaimers, I am a huge fan and quite in agreement with a lot of the problems Krishna has with the kutcheri format as we know it today. But I will stay as objective as I can narrating my experience. Krishna has been receiving a lot of flak, some of it warranted of course, but a lot of it is social media flogging based on second/third hand reports. I want my mostly positive reception of his experiments out in the cyberspace not really to counter these (to each his own, really) but to offer a different perspective for anybody who maybe wants to see another side to it.

The kutcheri format as we know it today, is mostly what was pioneered and optimized by Ariyakudi and was essentially one individual’s idea of how he wanted to present his music. That format having passed on over the generations has become a dictat on how a concert should be performed. But music and its presentation should never remain static, and any art is individual interpretation. When I start looking at Krishna’s attempts as something more than a “gimmick” and try to figure out why and how he is trying to shake up the format of a kutcheri, I see a lot of things that ring well with me, and some that maybe don’t. But I am willing to let that go in the wake of the fact that the unpredictability of what is going to come next adds an extra dimension of intrigue and wonder in the concert for me.

Now to the concert itself. Krishna delved straight into Ananda natana prakasham, in his vilamba kaala style,kedaram in all its glory! There was joy in the way the team performed this krithi.  There was a neraval @ sri kedaradhi kshetra which is not a typical spot for this krithi but quite a playful one. The twists, turns and swings around the word kedara were a delight! And then when they reached sangeetha vaadya vinodha, it didn’t seem unnatural at all that they decided to stop there again for neraval, the team was so into it at this point. After 30 minutes of kedaram they were finally satisfied and the audience was ecstatic. Who are we then  to complain that the first “warm-up piece” shouldn’t go on for so long! A thaanam in Sri Ranjini followed, and while personally I would have enjoyed an alapana better (just because of my love for the raagam), when Krishna segued into Marubalka, the pace of the thaanam really set the pace for the song. Now, if you have heard Semmangudi sing Marubalka with the lightning speed swaras and sangathis, you don’t want to hear it sung by anybody else that way. Krishna owned the song and really made it his own with a madhyamakala pace and awesome third speed swarams when Arun Prakash set it into motion with some energetic korvais. He really is the person who got the rawest of deals with all the vilamba kaala expositions, but his restrained minimalist style in those really sets him apart from everyone else. Next was a Saraswathi Manohari alapana (TMK announced it was the Diskthira paddhathi one, it sounded nothing like the Entha vedunkondu one and more like Kaanada IMO) and the eponymous krithi followed. I love Krishna for his love for Dikshitar!

Next  is where it gets interesting. Krishna sang and explored Mukhari beautifully in multiple octaves and then Sriramkumar took over and played a splendid Kedaragowla! And then Krishna began singing Kuvalayakshiro!!! I love Kshetragnya padams, and being married to a Movva from the land of Muvva Gopala, the Gowlipantu was a double delight. While I don’t have a huge issue with stand alone alapanas, I didn’t quite get the choice of ragas and so felt a little stumped and was searching for clues where there probably were none. And then Krishna took on  Poochi Srinivasa Iyengar’s Shankarabharanam thillana, and when Dharin turned to me in alarm that the concert was going to end, I only half jokingly told her that this was probably the main. Well, that is what it ended up being 🙂  After singing the thillana in its pure honest form at a reduced speed (which totally worked for me BTW) he then launched into a Shankarabharanam exploration over the hills and vales. Now if  I had tweeted my first knee jerk reaction to this, I am sure there would have been a flogging party over it. But when he and Shriramkumar were done with it, I was completely overwhelmed with the beauty of the shankarabharanam exposition. I didn’t find it incomplete, inappropriate or out of place. The thillana pallavi didn’t start at sammam, so Arun Prakash had super fun exploring this in his thani in his trademark controlled restrained way. I wont pretend I understood the math 🙂

Next up was the slokam Moulam Ganga (another Semmangudi staple) followed by a hamir kalyani alapana by RKSK and Sharade in Hameerkalyani.  A lovely Pantuvarali alapana with terrific exchanges between TMK and RKSK followed and I was super excited anticipating a Pallavi. TMK announced the raagam as Kamavardhini instead of Pantuvarali which made sense once the pallavi lines began ,” Parthadum mayanginen paavai yin paarvai yai” . The exposition was swarakshara filled at all the Pas and Mas. And then TMK and RKSK went into ragamalika mode with the pallavi. Krishna believes in a democratic stage, with him and Sriram Kumar and Arun Prakash sitting in an arc on stage. For probably the first time ever, I could see the violinst AND mridangist’s’ faces throughout the concert and it was lovely to watch the camaraderie. This pallavi ragamalika was a true duet, each one taking up a different raga : Ahiri (was like listening to Mayamma!), neelambari, hamsadhwani and ending with Khamas. Khamas segued into a fast paced  and a super fun javali (Era ra ra)! And Dhava vibho and mangalam kosalendra also sung in Yaman Kalyani wrapped up a splendid 3 hours of divine pure music.

Yes, the concert was non-conformal to what is the norm today, but each composition form and raga was performed in its purest state with full justice given to the grammar of the format. Dikshitar and Thiagaraja were represented, there was a pallavi, a padam, a jaavali, a thillana, multiple ghana raaga explorations and none of them felt incomplete at all. I don’t have a problem with the order when the treatment is so perfect. Krishna’s voice was in great form despite this being close to the end of the tour and they were truly a team on stage. Even the” this is not a concert” spiel was more like a request to try to understand the attempt , that it was just to share music.  And that is exactly what they did on stage, completely in consonance with each other and the music. The second request was to not feel compelled to applaud every time they came to a silence, and sometimes let the silence sink in, which was again a perfectly acceptable request (I fact checked this with my objective about everything and extremely rational husband and he said he didn’t spot any arrogance in the requests made).  My only gripe with the concert was that there was no varnam, and that too only because TMK sings them so well! A varnam main was what I had hoped for 🙂 Another complaint from some in my gang was that there were not enough madhyamakala krithis to balance the vilambam, and if  you are not a fan of slow explorations I guess his style can be a little hard to like. I am fine if people aren’t a fan of the music itself, but the all out bashing of all his attempts IMO is unwarranted. We shouldn’t be nit-picking over dictats which are probably 50-70 years old forgetting the beauty of the compositions much older and the music that predates everything else!

P.S – A more technical review of the concert here : http://www.rasikas.org/forum/viewtopic.php?f=13&t=24377

A really endearing acceptance speech from TMK recently where he re iterates the friendship this team shares : https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nA23S8AN0fI



Filed under Carnatic music, Concerts, Music

2 responses to “A Southern music

  1. nivik

    Wait this was not a technical review? 🙂 I am super glad the concert turned out to be great. Any nonconformity usually invites flak. It is possible that decades and decades of a certain format has made us creatures of habit and expectations and when someone crosses that line, it creates havoc. As you rightly pointed though as long as he as a musician satisfies his audience by providing food for the soul, that’s all that matters. Maybe (and this is a personal opinion), its possible that much of the music appreciating junta is not as well versed in the theoretical and varied compositions that a traditional concert does not offer and is turned of by not knowing what is going on. I am no way as knowledgeable as you are, for me identifying raagas in concerts is a huge victory and learning new raagas or compositions is a huge part of why I go to concerts. That might not be the case with everyone though. Again not justifying, just pondering. Like all new things, I think the un-concert needs time for people to get used to and by sticking to his gut and doing that for a few years now, he might just make believers out of all of the knowledgeable Chennai crowd.

    My only gripe with him as been his lack of command over what I can only call mood swings. Singing halfheartedly, stopping multiple times in the middle which comes across very evidently as lack of interest and playing right in to his mood swings paints a picture of a sometimes irresponsible musician who disappoints fans who don’t often get a chance to listen to great concerts. Maybe that’s the price one pays to listen to a genius.

    Also mega sad I couldnt make it to the bay area one! Lets hope he tours very soon.

    • dandilsa

      @Nivi- thanks for reading and responding 🙂 I agree that when you try to shake up things you tend to have to pay for it, but a lot of the social media flak is for the wrong reasons. I don’t necessarily think Krishna is bringing in new forms from what is traditionally heard, just that he sings fewer compositions and tries to go deeper into them, depth over variety. He sang close to 16 raagas yest,but only 8 actual compositions, which is a good balance ? As for your second point, I have been lucky enough to never have experienced it in all the concerts I have been to, there is no excuse for it and I won’t defend him for that.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s